SecondBrain › Mortgage broker tools › Escalating pricing guide
How to escalate a home loan pricing request (Australian brokers)
What to do when a lender's first offer isn't sharp enough: how escalation usually works, what lenders weigh, how to document a competing offer, when to stop, and what to record for Best Interests Duty.
Published by SecondBrain, which makes Sharp, an AI pricing assistant for pricing requests. Most of this guide is about process and works without any tool. Lender processes differ and change: this guide describes general practice, not any one lender's procedure, and where we mention a specific lender we link its own page. Confirm the current process with your BDM. General information only, not financial, credit or legal advice.
Short answer. Escalate through the channel each lender prefers (usually its broker portal or your BDM) with one clear ask: the specific rate you need, why it is justified (loan size, LVR, the client's income and relationship with the lender, or a documented competing offer) and the real deadline. Add new information each round rather than repeating the same request, track every request and response, and stop when the lender gives its final position or another option already meets the client's needs. Record it all on the file as you go: ASIC expects your records to show the options, the outcome and why you recommended what you did. Escalation is strongest when it starts from a full first-round comparison across your panel, which is the step a tool can speed up.
How pricing escalation usually works
A pricing request asks a lender what it will offer on a specific loan scenario. The sharper offers are usually discretionary pricing: a rate or fee concession below the lender's standard pricing, decided deal by deal. (For the basics of sending the first request, see our pricing requests guide.)
An escalation (some brokers call it a rate review or a pricing re-request) is going back to the lender when its first response doesn't meet the client's needs, and asking it to reconsider. In practice it usually looks like this:
- First round. You send the scenario to the lenders you're considering and get their first responses.
- Compare. You line the responses up against each other and against what the client needs (rate, fees, features, timing).
- Escalate selectively. You go back to one or two lenders whose product suits the client best, with a specific ask and a reason.
- Final position. The lender either sharpens its offer or confirms it can't. Some lenders have more than one level of pricing approval, so a larger concession may take longer.
- Recommend and record. You recommend the option that is in the client's best interests and record why.
The quality of step 3 depends on step 1. An escalation backed by a full comparison ("three lenders have come back below this on the same scenario") is a different conversation from "can you do any better?"
What lenders usually weigh
Every lender sets its own pricing policy and the weighting is not published in detail, so treat this as the common ground rather than any one lender's rules. Many lenders consider:
- Loan size. Larger loans often have more room for a concession.
- LVR. Lower LVR loans are generally lower risk to the lender. Moneysmart tells borrowers that having at least 20% equity gives them "more to bargain with".[1]
- Income and overall profile. The client's income, credit history and the strength of the application. Moneysmart also notes a good credit score helps with negotiations.[1]
- The client's existing relationship. Other lending, deposits or transaction accounts with that lender, and anything new coming across.
- A credible competing offer. Often the most direct reason for a lender to move. Moneysmart's own advice to borrowers refinancing starts with telling the current lender they plan to switch to a cheaper loan, because "to keep your business, your lender may reduce the interest rate".[1]
- Loan purpose and product. Owner-occupied or investment, principal and interest or interest-only, package or basic, fixed or variable.
Some lenders also publish pricing guidance to accredited brokers. CommBank, for example, says it gives accredited brokers its pricing discount table on CommBroker.[2] Checking published guidance first tells you whether a deal is already at the edge of what the lender usually offers, or whether there is room to ask.
Documenting a competing offer
If the escalation rests on a competing offer, its quality matters. A vague "another bank is cheaper" invites a vague reply. Before you rely on one, check:
- Which lender, the rate, and the fees (establishment, annual package, ongoing)
- The product and its features (offset, redraw, package benefits)
- Same scenario: loan amount, LVR, purpose, repayment type and fixed or variable term
- Whether it is a formal approval or an indicative response, and in writing
- When it expires
- That you are sharing only what the lender's process needs, through its approved channel
Compare like with like. A lower headline rate on a package with a higher annual fee, or without an offset the client will use, may not be the cheaper loan. ASIC makes the same point in its Best Interests Duty guidance: the product with the lowest interest rate "is not necessarily the lowest cost option for all consumers".[3]
Client details, including what is in another lender's offer, are personal information under the Privacy Act. Share the minimum the lender's pricing process needs.
Working with your BDM
For most brokers the escalation route is the lender's broker portal, the BDM, or both. The Business Development Manager is the broker's contact at the lender; Macquarie, for example, describes its BDMs as being there "to support you through the full life cycle" and offers chat inside its broker portal.[4] CommBank assigns accredited brokers a Relationship Manager.[2] Names and structures differ by lender.
Practical habits that tend to help:
- Ask each BDM how they want escalations sent: through the portal, by email, or by phone first. Use that channel and don't send the same escalation everywhere at once.
- Lead with the specific ask. "We need 0.10% sharper to keep this with you" is easier to act on than "anything you can do?"
- Give the reason and the evidence in the first message, not on the third follow-up.
- Be accurate. Overstating a competing offer damages a relationship you'll rely on for the next deal.
- Know who covers when your BDM is away, so a deadline doesn't slip.
Turnaround expectations
Turnaround for an escalated pricing request varies by lender, deal size and how far the ask is from the lender's usual pricing. Larger concessions may need sign-off from someone more senior, which takes longer. Lenders don't generally publish turnaround times for pricing escalations, so rather than relying on a rule of thumb:
- Give the real deadline and the reason (an expiring approval, an auction, a settlement date).
- Ask how long the approved price holds, so it is still valid when the loan settles.
- Log when each request went out and when it came back. Over a few months you'll learn which lenders are quick to respond.
- Avoid sending escalations late on a Friday if the deadline is Monday morning.
An escalation template
When to stop escalating
Escalating has costs: time, the client's patience, and goodwill with the lender. It is usually time to stop when:
- The lender has confirmed its final position.
- You have no new information to add. Asking again with the same facts rarely changes the answer.
- The client's deadline (an approval expiring, a settlement date) is at risk.
- Another option already meets the client's needs, once fees, features and timing are counted, not just the rate.
- The remaining gap is small compared with differences in fees or features that matter more to the client.
The goal is the outcome that is in the client's best interests, not winning the last basis point.
Best Interests Duty record keeping
Mortgage brokers must act in the best interests of the consumer when providing credit assistance (sections 158LA and 158LE of the National Consumer Credit Protection Act). ASIC's Regulatory Guide 273 sets out how it expects brokers to comply.[3] It says it generally expects records that include, among other things:
- "information provided to the credit provider as part of the application process";
- "outcomes of credit applications";
- "relevant conversations with the consumer"; and
- "the options and ultimate recommendation you gave and the reasons why (including a detailed description of your decision-making process)".[3]
RG 273 also notes records can include correspondence, file notes and "outputs of product and feature comparison tools", and that taking notes as you go "may help you to accurately capture your thinking and reasoning at each relevant point in time".[3] For a pricing escalation, that usually means keeping on the client file:
- Each pricing request sent, to which lender, and when
- Each lender's response, including the first offer and any revised offer
- Any competing offer you relied on, and how you checked it was like for like
- What you discussed with the client (rate versus fees and features, timing)
- The option you recommended, and why, including why you didn't choose a cheaper-looking alternative
Your licensee may have its own requirements on top of this; follow them.
Where Sharp fits
Escalation is a judgement call and a relationship, and it stays with you. What a tool can speed up is the first round: getting each lender's response to the same scenario back, side by side, so you escalate from a full comparison rather than one or two quotes.
Sharp by SecondBrain our product
Sharp is an AI pricing assistant for Australian mortgage brokers that runs in Microsoft Teams and Google Chat. You send one pricing request; Sharp sends it to each lender you choose, through that lender's own portal and under your own login, and returns the lenders' responses side by side, in about 4 minutes against 30–45 minutes doing it manually. You make every decision, including whether to escalate, with which lender, and what to recommend. Sharp doesn't escalate or contact anyone on your behalf. Pricing is A$190 per broker per month monthly, A$147 quarterly or A$125 annually (ex GST), and support staff are free. See how Sharp works, the Sharp FAQ and the help centre.
It isn't worth it if you write a handful of loans a month or your panel is one or two lenders. If you're weighing a general AI chatbot instead, see Sharp vs ChatGPT. For broker software by job, see Mortgage broker software and AI tools in Australia.
Glossary
- Pricing request
- A broker's request to a lender for its pricing on a specific loan scenario.
- Discretionary pricing
- A rate or fee concession below a lender's standard pricing, decided deal by deal.
- Pricing escalation
- Going back to a lender after its first pricing response to ask it to reconsider, usually with a specific ask and a reason.
- LVR
- Loan-to-value ratio: the loan amount as a percentage of the security's value.
- Best Interests Duty
- The obligation on mortgage brokers to act in the consumer's best interests when providing credit assistance.
More terms in the mortgage broker automation glossary.
Escalate from a full comparison
See how Sharp gets the first round of lender pricing back side by side, from Teams or Google Chat.
See how Sharp works Book a call with JamesFrequently asked questions
How do I escalate a home loan pricing request when the first offer isn't sharp enough?
Go back through the channel the lender prefers (usually the broker portal or your BDM) with one clear ask: the specific rate you need, the reason it is justified (loan size, LVR, the client's relationship with the lender, or a documented competing offer) and the real deadline. Add only new information each round, track when you asked and what came back, and stop when the lender confirms its final position or another option already meets the client's needs.
What do lenders usually look at when reviewing a pricing escalation?
It varies by lender, but many weigh the loan size, the LVR, the client's income and overall profile, the client's existing relationship with the lender (other lending, deposits, anything new coming across) and whether there is a credible competing offer. Each lender decides its own pricing deal by deal.
Should I show a lender a competing offer?
A competing offer is often the strongest reason for a lender to sharpen its price, so if you have one, document it: the lender, rate, fees, product, whether it is an approval or an indication, and when it expires. Compare like with like (same loan amount, LVR, repayment type and product features), only share what the lender's process needs through its approved channel, and remember client details are personal information under the Privacy Act.
When should I stop escalating a pricing request?
Stop when the lender confirms its final position, when you have no new information to add, when the client's deadline is at risk, or when another option already meets the client's needs. The lowest rate is not always the best outcome for the client: ASIC's guidance notes fees and features can make a lower-rate loan more expensive overall.
What should I record for Best Interests Duty when escalating pricing?
ASIC's Regulatory Guide 273 says it expects brokers to keep records including information provided to the credit provider, outcomes of applications, relevant conversations with the consumer, and the options and recommendation given with the reasons why. For an escalation, that usually means each pricing request and response, any competing offer relied on, and why you recommended the final option, recorded as you go.
Does Sharp escalate pricing for me?
No. Sharp handles the first round: you send one pricing request, Sharp sends it to each lender you choose through that lender's own portal under your own login, and returns the lenders' responses side by side, in about 4 minutes. You decide whether and how to escalate, with whom, and what to recommend.
Sources
- Moneysmart (ASIC), "Switching home loans" ("Tell your current lender you are planning to switch to a cheaper loan…"; "If you have at least 20% equity in your home, you'll have more to bargain with"; "Having a good credit score will also help with negotiations"). moneysmart.gov.au/home-loans/switching-home-loans (accessed 28 Oct 2026)
- CommBank residential broker page ("We provide more transparency around pricing by providing our accredited brokers with our pricing discount table", available on CommBroker; Relationship Manager for accredited brokers). commbank.com.au/home-loans/residential-broker.html (accessed 28 Oct 2026)
- ASIC, Regulatory Guide 273 Mortgage brokers: Best interests duty (June 2020), RG 273.6, RG 273.56, RG 273.165, RG 273.167 and RG 273.169. asic.gov.au RG 273 and full guide (PDF) (accessed 28 Oct 2026)
- Macquarie broker page ("business development managers are here to support you through the full life cycle"; "Start a chat in Macquarie Broker Portal at any time"). macquarie.com.au/brokers.html (accessed 28 Oct 2026)
Definitions follow the SecondBrain glossary. Sharp facts are from the Sharp page and Sharp FAQ. Related: How to get home loan pricing requests back faster · Sharp help centre · Sharp vs ChatGPT.
General information only. This guide is not financial, credit or legal advice and doesn't take any client's circumstances into account. Lender processes and pricing change; confirm with each lender and follow your licensee's requirements.