Sharp vs doing it yourself with ChatGPT

For most Australian mortgage brokers, the real alternative to Sharp isn't other software. It's using ChatGPT or Copilot yourself, handing the job to a support person or offshore VA, or just doing it by hand. Here's an honest look at when each makes sense.

By James Larkey, founder of SecondBrain · Last reviewed: 27 October 2026 · ~6 min read

The short version. ChatGPT can write about a pricing request. Sharp makes the request. You enter the scenario once in Microsoft Teams or Google Chat, Sharp requests pricing from each lender you choose using your own lender login, and the results come back in the same chat.

Want to see it sooner? Book a call and we'll run one live with you.

The honest answer

Just use ChatGPT (or Copilot) if…

  • You mostly need help writing: client emails, file notes, summaries, plain-English explanations.
  • You only request discretionary pricing occasionally, and doing it by hand is fine.
  • You price with one or two lenders, so there's little to compare.
  • You already have a business AI plan your licensee has approved.

Use Sharp if…

  • You or your team regularly request pricing from several lenders for the same client.
  • That time is coming out of broker hours, or out of a support person's day.
  • You want requests made under each broker's own lender login, not by someone retyping into portals.
  • Your team already works in Microsoft Teams or Google Chat.

Plenty of brokers will use both: a general AI assistant for writing, and Sharp for getting pricing from lenders. They aren't really competing for the same job.

Sounds like your team? See it on one of your own files.

What ChatGPT is genuinely good at

General-purpose AI assistants such as ChatGPT, Claude and Microsoft Copilot are useful from day one with almost no setup. For a broker, that means drafting client and lender emails, summarising long documents and call notes, explaining loan structures (offset vs redraw, fixed vs variable splits) in plain English, and turning rough notes into tidy file notes or comparison write-ups. If that's where your time goes, start there.

Two cautions. First, an assistant's answer about a lender's rate or policy is generated text, not a quote from the lender, so check anything factual before it reaches a client (see AI accountability for brokers). Second, some ChatGPT and Copilot plans now include agent features that can operate a web browser. We haven't tested those against lender portals. If you go down that path, you're the one building and maintaining it: the prompts for each lender, the sign-in steps, and what happens when a portal changes.

Task by task

TaskDoing it yourself with ChatGPT / CopilotSharp
Draft a client or lender emailVery good. Fast, flexible, and the main reason to use it.Not what Sharp is for. Keep using your AI assistant or your own templates.
Submit a pricing requestCan write the request. You still log in to each lender's portal or email their pricing team, and enter the scenario each time.Enter the scenario once in chat. Sharp requests pricing from each lender you pick, under your own lender login.
Chase each lender and compare the resultsCan draft the follow-up email. You track who replied, chase the rest and line the answers up yourself.Results come back to the same chat, lender by lender, so you can see what's back and what still needs a follow-up. You keep the relationship with each lender.
Order valuations (e.g. PropertyHub)Can draft the order details. You lodge it in each lender's valuation portal.Separate SecondBrain valuations app: one order form, lodged through each lender's valuation portal (including PropertyHub by Cotality) with your firm's logins, with a status command to track orders.
Where you use itIts own app or browser tab. Copilot also appears inside Microsoft 365 apps.Inside Microsoft Teams or Google Chat, where your team already talks.
Setup and upkeepMinimal to start. Ongoing: prompts or templates per lender to maintain, and staff habits to build and keep consistent.SecondBrain sets up your firm and connects each broker's lender logins; your IT or Workspace admin installs the app. We maintain the lender connections.
Client dataDepends on the plan and settings your staff use. Pasting client details into a consumer chatbot is a privacy question for a credit licensee (see below).Receives the loan scenario and client name. Hosted in Australia, with each broker's lender login in an isolated Microsoft Key Vault.
CostFree tiers and paid plans, priced by OpenAI and Microsoft. Plus your staff time.A$190 per broker per month billed monthly, A$147 billed quarterly, or A$125 billed annually, ex GST. Plus less staff time (estimate it below).

Comparison reflects Sharp as described on our product and legal pages and general-purpose AI assistants as publicly available, as at 27 October 2026. Third-party products change; check their current features and terms.

The parts of "doing it yourself" that don't show up on day one

Prompts per lender, and someone to keep them working

Each lender asks for pricing differently. A DIY approach ends up with a prompt or template per lender, a person who knows which one to use, and a fix whenever a lender changes its form. That's fine for one broker who enjoys it. It gets harder across a team.

Staff habits

A tool only saves time if everyone uses it the same way. With a general assistant, every broker and support person builds their own habits. Sharp gives the team one way to request pricing, in the chat app they already use.

Client data in a consumer chatbot

Client names, incomes and loan details are personal information, and an Australian credit licensee has obligations about where that information goes. The Office of the Australian Information Commissioner (OAIC) recommends, as a matter of best practice, that organisations do not enter personal information, and particularly sensitive information, into publicly available generative AI tools.[1] Business plans of AI assistants often come with different data terms from free accounts, so check your licensee's AI policy and the plan your staff actually use.

Sharp is not a way around privacy obligations either. It handles personal information too: the scenario and the client's name. It runs as the broker, under the broker's own accredited lender login, inside Microsoft Teams or Google Chat. Data is hosted in Australia, each broker's lender login sits in an isolated Microsoft Key Vault, and our Privacy Policy sets out what we collect and keep.[2] The details for security reviewers are in How Sharp Works.

Calculator: what is pricing costing you in time?

This estimates the staff time spent on pricing requests today, and what it would cost with Sharp, using your own figures. We haven't filled in "minutes per request with Sharp" for you: time it on a trial, or ask us to run one with you.

Example figures, not ours. The pre-filled numbers are examples only. Change them to your own figures. Results are estimates from your inputs, not a promise of savings.

Example: 20. Change to your own figure.
Brokers who would each have a Sharp subscription.
Example: 30. Include logging in, entering the scenario, chasing and comparing.
Left blank on purpose. Your time to enter the scenario and review the results.
Example: A$60. Use a broker's or support person's loaded hourly cost.
Published prices, ex GST.
Today
–
–
With Sharp: staff time
–
Enter your minutes with Sharp
Sharp subscription
–
–

Fill in your figures to see an estimate.

Estimates from your inputs only. Monthly figures. Staff cost = hours × your hourly cost. Sharp subscription = brokers × plan price, ex GST. It doesn't count rate outcomes, client experience or the cost of mistakes, in either direction.

Time it on one of your own files

Book a 30-minute call with James and we'll run a real pricing request with you, so the "with Sharp" number in the calculator is yours, not ours.

What about a support person or offshore VA?

That's the other common choice, and it's a reasonable one: a person can do many jobs across the file, not just pricing. The trade-offs are cost, training, and handing your lender access to someone else. We've written a separate comparison: SecondBrain vs offshore processing. Sharp and a support person aren't exclusive. Sharp takes the portal work off their plate.

Frequently asked questions

Can ChatGPT do my bank pricing requests?

ChatGPT can help you write a pricing request: the email to a lender's pricing team, a summary of the scenario, or a client-facing explanation of the options. It does not hold your lender accreditation, log in to lender portals as you, or submit the request through each lender's process. You still do the submitting, the chasing and the comparing. Sharp does the submitting: you enter the scenario once in Microsoft Teams or Google Chat and it requests pricing from each lender you choose, under your own lender login, and returns the results in the same chat.

Is ChatGPT good for mortgage brokers?

Yes, for writing and thinking work. ChatGPT, Claude and Microsoft Copilot are genuinely useful for drafting client emails, summarising notes and documents, explaining loan structures in plain English and turning rough notes into tidy documents. Check anything factual, such as rates or lender policy, against the lender before it reaches a client.

Is it a privacy problem to paste client details into ChatGPT?

It can be. Client names, incomes and loan details are personal information, and a credit licensee has obligations about where that information goes. The Office of the Australian Information Commissioner recommends, as a matter of best practice, that organisations do not enter personal information, and particularly sensitive information, into publicly available generative AI tools. Check your licensee's AI policy and which ChatGPT or Copilot plan your staff actually use. Sharp also handles personal information: it receives the loan scenario and the client's name, under SecondBrain's Privacy Policy, and stores it in Australia.

What does Sharp cost compared with ChatGPT?

Sharp is priced per broker, per month, excluding GST: A$190 billed monthly, A$147 billed quarterly or A$125 billed annually. ChatGPT and Microsoft Copilot have free tiers and paid plans priced by OpenAI and Microsoft; check their current pricing. The bigger cost in either case is usually staff time, which is what the calculator on this page estimates from your own figures.

Should I use ChatGPT and Sharp together?

Many brokers will. They do different jobs. Use a general AI assistant for writing and summarising, and Sharp for getting pricing from your lenders. If you rarely request discretionary pricing, ChatGPT plus your current process may be all you need.

Does Sharp replace my support person or VA?

Not entirely. Sharp handles one job: requesting pricing from your lenders and bringing the results back into chat. A support person does many jobs. Some brokerages use Sharp so their support staff spend less time in lender portals and more time on the rest of the file.

Sources

Last reviewed: 27 October 2026. We'll re-review this page when Sharp or the assistants it's compared with change materially.

  1. Office of the Australian Information Commissioner, Guidance on privacy and the use of commercially available AI products (published 21 October 2024). oaic.gov.au
  2. SecondBrain, Privacy Policy (Sharp in Microsoft Teams and Google Chat, and the valuations app), and How Sharp Works.
  3. Sharp in Google Chat: Sharp Pricing for Google Chat and Sharp Valuations for Google Chat. Valuations in Microsoft Teams: SecondBrain Valuations Agent.
  4. Sharp plans and prices: secondbrain.com.au/sharp.
  5. Broker Daily, "Automated pricing tool for brokers launches", 11 September 2026. brokerdaily.au